The first pair I got had a defect in the lining. Sent them back and got another pair.The second pair fit well, were lite, and felt stable in them. My only hold up was that the boot's insoles were the thinnest I've ever seen. The only reason I didn't change them was because I had no time to change them out. That being said, I have been working with them for 2 months now and they are still as comfortable as the day I got them. It's an enginma. The material is still holding up too. I still recommend to get insoles for most people, but I'm going to rock the thin insoles until it get annoying. I'm glad I gave them a second chance.